When a customer slips in a tenant's store, or a fire starts in a tenant's kitchen, the first question is whose insurance pays. If your leases and your tenants' policies are set up right, the answer is usually theirs. If they aren't, it can be yours, along with the hit to your loss history and your next renewal.
Your lease should spell out exactly what insurance each tenant carries, and the tenant's policy should name you as an additional insured by endorsement. A certificate of insurance is evidence, not coverage. Collect certificates at move-in and every renewal, and check them against the lease.
Why tenant insurance protects you
Under a lessor's risk program, your policy covers the building and your liability as owner. Your tenants' policies are meant to cover their operations. When a claim comes from what a tenant is doing, their insurance should respond first. Every claim that lands on your policy instead counts against your loss history, even if you were barely involved.
The tenant insurance checklist
1. Commercial general liability
Require general liability with limits that fit the tenant's business. Many leases start at $1,000,000 per occurrence and $2,000,000 aggregate. Higher-risk uses, like restaurants, bars, fitness studios, medical offices, and daycare, often warrant higher limits or an umbrella.
2. Additional insured status for you
The tenant's liability policy should name you, and your property manager if you have one, as additional insureds through an endorsement. A common standard form is written specifically for managers or lessors of premises. Ask to see the endorsement itself, not just a box checked on a certificate.
3. Primary and noncontributory wording
This language means the tenant's policy pays first for covered claims arising from the tenant's operations, without asking your policy to share the loss. Without it, the two insurers may split the claim, and your policy takes part of the hit.
4. Waiver of subrogation
After paying a claim, an insurer can try to recover its money from whoever caused the loss. A mutual waiver of subrogation in the lease, supported by endorsements on both policies, keeps your insurer and your tenant's insurer from suing each other's insureds over covered losses. Make sure the lease and both policies match.
5. Property coverage for the tenant's contents and improvements
Your building policy doesn't cover the tenant's inventory, equipment, or furniture. Depending on the lease, it may not cover improvements the tenant paid for either. Require tenants to insure their own property, and spell out who insures improvements.
6. Business income for the tenant
A tenant with no income after a fire may stop paying rent and walk away. Requiring business income coverage helps them survive a shutdown and keeps the relationship intact. It doesn't replace your own loss of rents coverage.
7. Workers' compensation, auto, and liquor liability where they apply
Tenants with employees should carry workers' compensation as Illinois requires. Tenants that sell or serve alcohol should carry liquor liability, since that exposure is generally excluded from general liability. Tenants that use vehicles on your property should carry auto liability.
8. Notice of cancellation
Ask that tenants notify you if their coverage is cancelled or not renewed. Insurers don't always notify certificate holders automatically, so put the obligation on the tenant in the lease.
A certificate isn't coverage
The standard certificate of insurance most tenants send is informational. It shows what a policy looked like on the day it was issued, and it usually says that it doesn't amend, extend, or alter the policy. If the additional insured endorsement isn't actually on the tenant's policy, a certificate that says "additional insured" won't put it there.
For your larger and higher-risk tenants, ask for copies of the endorsements as well as the certificate.
Tracking certificates
- Collect at move-in, before keys are handed over.
- Track expiration dates and request renewals before policies expire.
- Check each certificate against the lease: limits, additional insured, waiver, and the correct names and property address.
- Follow up on gaps in writing, and keep records.
- Extend the same rules to vendors like snow removal, landscaping, and contractors working on the property.
We'll review the insurance section of your leases and check tenant certificates against it, so you know where the gaps are before a claim finds them.
Ask about tenant COI reviewThis article is general information, not legal advice. Your attorney should draft or review the insurance and indemnity provisions in your leases. Coverage is subject to the terms of each policy and underwriting approval.