The building limit on your property policy is one of the most important numbers you'll ever sign off on, and one of the most commonly wrong. Set it too low and a large loss can leave you short. With a coinsurance clause, even a small loss can pay less than you expect.
Your building limit should match what it would cost to rebuild the building today, not what you paid for it or what it would sell for. If your policy has a coinsurance clause and your limit is too low, the insurer can reduce any claim payment, not just a total loss.
Market value is the wrong number
Owners often set their building limit based on the purchase price, an appraisal for a loan, or the assessed value. None of those measure what it costs to rebuild.
- Market value includes the land, which doesn't burn down, and reflects rents, location, and cap rates.
- Replacement cost is what it would cost to rebuild the same building with materials of like kind and quality at today's construction prices.
The two can be far apart. A vintage masonry courtyard building or an older brick walk-up may sell for less than it would cost to rebuild, especially with plaster walls, ornamental details, and today's labor costs. Investors who buy below market are often underinsured without realizing it.
How coinsurance works
Many commercial property policies include a coinsurance clause, commonly 80%, 90%, or 100%. It requires you to carry a building limit of at least that percentage of the building's replacement cost. If you carry less, the insurer reduces your claim payment in proportion to the shortfall, even on a partial loss.
The calculation in many policies works like this: divide the limit you carried by the limit you should have carried, multiply that by the loss, then subtract your deductible.
A building would cost $4,000,000 to rebuild. The policy has a 90% coinsurance clause, so the owner needs to carry at least $3,600,000. The owner carries $2,700,000, based on an old valuation.
A fire causes $400,000 of damage. The deductible is $10,000.
$2,700,000 ÷ $3,600,000 = 75%. 75% × $400,000 = $300,000. Minus the $10,000 deductible, the insurer pays $290,000. The owner covers the remaining $110,000, on a loss well under the policy limit.
What replacement cost should include
A good valuation accounts for the building's actual construction, square footage, number of stories, quality of finishes, and local labor and material costs. Some costs are usually handled separately, so make sure they're addressed:
- Code upgrades. Rebuilding an older building can require modern electrical, sprinklers, or accessibility. That's covered by ordinance or law coverage, not the base building limit.
- Demolition and debris removal. Policies often limit these, and they can be expensive after a major loss.
- Lost rent. Rental income during the rebuild is a separate coverage, and rebuilding often takes longer than owners expect.
Agreed value: a way around coinsurance
Many carriers offer an agreed value option. You submit a statement of values, the insurer accepts it, and the coinsurance clause is suspended for the policy term. It's worth asking about, especially for buildings that are hard to value.
Condo associations have a specific requirement
The Illinois Condominium Property Act requires the association's property insurance to be written for the full insurable replacement cost, and the board should review that value at purchase and at every renewal. See what Illinois condo associations are required to carry.
How to keep your limit right
- Get a professional insurance appraisal every few years, especially for larger or older buildings.
- Update values at every renewal between appraisals, using current construction cost trends.
- Tell your agent about renovations, additions, and major upgrades that change what it would cost to rebuild.
- Read the coinsurance percentage on your declarations page, and ask whether agreed value is available.
We'll compare your current limits to rebuild costs, check your coinsurance terms, and show you what a large loss would look like under your current policy.
Request a coverage reviewThis article is general information, not legal advice. Policy terms, including how coinsurance is calculated, vary by carrier and form. Coverage is subject to the terms of each policy and underwriting approval.